From the Vine
  • I've moved to craiglehoullier.com

More on Tomatopalooza.....

8/3/2010

3 Comments

 

Just added morning of August 3 (HOW can it be August already?!)

Here is a link to my friend Dean's impressions of Tomatopalooza - including some great pictures (Sue and I vote the pic of Dean's daughter with the tomato balloons as best of show!)

I've discussed the various miracles in tomato supplies and superb organization and support.  So let's get down to it and discuss the true stars of the show - the tomatoes!


I am going to refer to Brian's lovely, labeled pictures to jog my memory of what I tasted.  But first....at a general level, we had lots of reds and pinks, a pretty good supply of "blacks" (the unusual purple or brown tomatoes), yellows, oranges and bicolors.  For whatever reason, we were really short on white and green fruited varieties.  Though a much smaller representation than the past few years, the Dwarf tomato project table was an interesting place to taste and hang around, and showed once again the promise that the project holds.


So, on to what I tasted and what I thought about it (and I am pretty ruthless when tasting tomatoes!).  Alphabetically (again, following Brian's pics):


Aussie - bland - 5/10
Banksia Queen F4 - a pleasant surprise - 7.5
Beefywine - not bad, a bit crunchy - underripe? - 6
Beryl Beauty F6 - nice, I've had better, though - 7
Blazing Beauty F4 - very nice, Tim! - promising - 7.5 (not quite as orange as what the F3 showed, still segregating)
Bloody Butcher - YUCK!  a spitter....1
Brandywine OTV - one of the best of the day - superb - 8
Brandywine Sudduth - superb - 8.5 (always one of my favorites)
Chapman - dry, crunchy - underripe? - 4
Cherokee Green - I love that tomato - 8
Cuostralee - the pink one from Heirloom Seeds - nothing there! - 4
Dr Carolyn's Pink - had a musky, cooked flavor - 5
Druzba - bland - 5.5
Eva Purple Ball - average to pleasant - 6
German Johnson - typical - mild, sweet, a bit lacking - 6.5
Granny Cantrell - pretty good - a bit too mild - 6.5
Green Doctors - better than Green Grape, but still....5.5
Green Grape  - just don't like it very much - 5
KBX - a really nice tomato - balanced, flavorful - 7.5
Kelly Green - one of the better advanced dwarfs - 7.5
Little Lucky - tasty, a bit hollow - I've had better - 6.5
Mortgage Lifter Pale Leaf - mild and sweet - 7
Mr. Snow - one of the best of the tasting - great dwarf! - 8
Nepal -interesting!  Fruit I brought - superb - 8; fruit others brought - watery, bland - 5.  A lesson here.
Perth Pride - another best in tasting - bright, tart, complex - 7.5
Plentiful F2 - great competitor to Tasmanian chocolate- tasty! - 7.5
Porky F3 - a bit dry, mealy, bland - nice size purple heart for a dwarf - 5.5
Purple Haze - intense, but a bit of a cooked flavor - 6.5
Purple Haze X P20 - weird!  more fruit (berry) like - 4 (nearly a spitter!)
Red Brandywine - again, interesting - one sample bland, 5; another sample (different source) balanced and flavorful, 7
Rosella Crimson - two different fruit - 6 and 7 (one overripe, one underripe?)
Rosella Purple - very nice, and it can even be better - 7.5
Rosy indeterminate - pretty nice - 6.5
Rosy, orange fruit - very nice, great potential - 7.5
Rosy pink - two different fruit, similar flavors - fair - 6
Rosy purple fruit - very nice! - 7
Sarandipity - two fruit (two plants) - both average in flavor - 5.5
Snowy F2 from red - four different fruits - none of them stood out, one was awful - ranked from 2 to 6
Summertime Green - a bit overripe, can show much better - 6
Sunny F2 - three different fruit, I liked the orange one best - 5-6 range for all three
Sungold - interesting!  Tasted from two different bowls.  One was the real deal - 9! - the other must have been from saved seed - good but lacked the punch - 6.5
Sweet Sue - my F6 plant isn't the choice selection - good but not great - 6.5
Tasmanian Chocolate - I really liked it, best I've tasted - 7.5
Variegated - average tomato flavor - 6
Wild Fred - flavor just wasn't there in this selection - 6
Williams Striped- one of the better bicolors I've tasted - 7
Winsall - nice pink tomato, well balanced - 7.5
Witty - not as good as what I tasted at Lee's - 6
Yellow Brandywine - outstanding tomato - 8


So as I look through this list, somehow I managed to taste 60 varieties - and was ready to start eating tomatoes again the very next day!


Best tomatoes I tasted - Perth Pride, Dwarf Mr. Snow, Banksia Queen, Brandywine OTV, Brandywine Sudduth, Yellow Brandywine, Sungold, Cherokee Green (8 varieties stood out for me)


Worst tomatoes I tasted - Snowy from Red hybrid, white cherry; Purple Haze X P20; Bloody Butcher, Aussie, Chapman, imposter Nepal, imposter Red Brandywine. (7 varieties scraped the bottom).


OK, blog readers who attended Tomatopalooza - send me your lists to post!






  
3 Comments
discrepancy
8/3/2010 04:22:50 am

How many Cuostralees got sliced up? The Cuostralee sample I had tasted similar to the Brandywine OTV, just the OTV had more of an acidic bite. Best tomato I've ever tasted, with OTV a very close second.

Two sources of Red Brandywine, eh. Whew! That's a relief! I was about to run screaming into the loving arms of Cuostralee and Brandywine OTV. The Sudduth's Brandywine I tried almost made me gag, too -- watery and bitter. What a letdown.

Reply
Darrel W. Jones link
8/3/2010 05:51:26 pm

Just a thought re the PH X P20 F3 that Craig sampled. I deliberately picked a fruit that I knew would taste horrible. I have another plant that produces an exceptionally good flavored fruit. Unfortunately, there were no ripe fruit from the good flavored plant to bring to Tomatopalooza.

Reply
David (Homegrownsnob)
8/4/2010 12:20:51 pm

Hi Craig,
This David I was the guy at TomatoPalooza in the red surf shirt from Charlotte. Wanted to ask if you could post best tasting tomatoes 1-4 or 5 like you did last year. Wanted to see what other tomatoes people thought tasted good as well as my Black Cherry I brought to the event. Maybe I missed a tomato I should grow for next year;).
I looked at your list of tomatoes you tasted UNfortunatly you did not try any I had brought;( . Beef Steak, Blk Cherry, Chero. Purple, ILda, Indian Stripe, Tenn. Blk. Would have liked your opinion;) NEXT TomatoPalooza I will be running around with a plate asking you try this tomato an that HE HE. I think I saw a few people doing that;) Cheers David

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Links

    • Seedlings Sewn
    • Tomatopalooza 2012 
    • Victory Seeds
    • The Year Round Veggie Gardener 
    • Seed Savers Exchange
    • Straw Bale Gardening
    • Dave's Garden
    • Tomatoville
    • Selected Plants
    • Tomato Growers Supply Company
    • Johnny's Selected Seeds
    • Southern Exposure Seed Exchange
    • Sandhill Preservation

    Archives

    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    January 2010
    October 2009
    September 2009

    Categories

    All
    2010 Events
    2011 Garden Update
    2011 Season
    2011 Tomato Harvest
    2014 Season
    Beets
    Black Cherry
    Bleaching
    Caging
    Canning
    Chard
    Cherokee Chocolate
    Comparing
    Container Gardening
    Cooking
    Cooking School
    Craig's Tomato Creations
    Dad
    Daily Stuff
    Daniel Stowe Garden
    Desert Island Tomatoes
    Dwarf Project
    Dwarf Sweet Sue
    Dwarf Tomato Project
    Eggplant
    End Of 2010 Report
    Event
    Favorites For 2009
    Fertilizing
    Flowers
    Garden Issues
    Garden Lessons
    Garden Progress
    Garden Tasks
    Garden Update
    Germinating Seeds
    Germination
    Greens
    Grow Bags
    Growing Medium
    Harvest
    Helping Friends
    Herbs
    History
    Hot Peppers
    Hybrid
    Indeterminate Tomatoes
    Kayaking
    Kitchen Renovation
    Lettuce
    Library
    Lillians Yellow
    Little Lucky
    Lucky Cross
    Monticello
    News
    Newspaper Article
    Office
    On The Radio
    Ornamental Hot Peppers
    Peppers
    Pictures
    Pots
    Recipe
    Recipes
    Robins Nest B&B
    Sara
    Sara's Book
    Seed Family Trees
    Seedlings
    Seed Saving
    Shannons
    Southern Season
    Sse
    Staking
    Suckering
    Sungold
    Sunset Beach
    Sweet Peppers
    Tomato Culture Q&A
    Tomato Culture Videos 2011
    Tomato Dinner
    Tomatoes
    Tomato Histories
    Tomatopalooza 2010
    Tomatopalooza 2010 Videos
    Tomatopalooza 2011
    Tomatopalooza 9 2011
    Tomato Tasting
    Topping
    Transplanting
    Tshirts
    Varieties Grown In 2010
    Video Updates 2010
    Video Updates 2011
    Watering
    Zely And Ritz

    RSS Feed